When considering whether to install a heater or a heat pump in your Melbourne home, there are several important factors to weigh. The Melbourne climate is known for its variability—four seasons in a day—so it’s crucial to choose a heating solution that will be efficient, effective, and suitable for your needs year-round.
Heating with Electric Heaters
If you’re searching for an affordable and efficient way to heat your home, electric heaters are a solid option. While they may have a higher upfront cost than some alternatives, electric heaters are generally less expensive to operate over time. They’re also easier to install and don’t rely on fuel sources like gas or propane.
There are many different electric heater types available depending on what you’re looking for. If portability is a priority, a mobile electric heater could be ideal, allowing you to warm up different rooms as needed.
These portable units are ideal for smaller rooms and only require a standard power outlet. Other common electric heating solutions in Melbourne include:
- Panel heaters (great for bedrooms but with low heat output)
- Oil column heaters (heat air effectively but take longer)
- Underfloor electric heating
- Radiant bar or fan heaters
No matter the type, electric heaters tend to be highly efficient, converting most of the power they draw into heat. This makes them more cost-effective over time, and since they produce no emissions, they’re also a greener choice for the environmentally conscious.
Heating with Heat Pumps
Heat pumps use minimal electricity to transfer heat from one place to another. They are often used for both heating and cooling, making them an all-in-one climate control solution. They operate similarly to air conditioners, but can reverse the cycle to provide heat during winter.
Heat pumps are best suited to temperate climates, which makes them a good match for Melbourne. While they can be less effective in extremely cold conditions, they still offer solid performance across much of the year in Melbourne’s relatively mild winters.
There are two main heat pump types: air-source and ground-source. Air-source pumps are more common and absorb heat from the air outside, while ground-source pumps draw heat from the earth’s more stable temperature levels.
Heat pump systems available for Melbourne homes include:
- Wall-mounted units
- Multi-split systems
- Floor-mounted models
- Ducted central systems
- Ceiling cassette heat pumps
Thanks to their energy efficiency and dual functionality, heat pumps are a great option for anyone looking to reduce their overall power use and long-term energy costs.
Heat pump vs electric heaters – which costs less to run?
If you’re comparing costs, it’s essential to look at both the upfront price and the ongoing running costs. Heat pumps are generally more efficient, so they tend to save you more over time. However, their installation costs are higher.
Electric heaters, by contrast, are cheaper to buy and install but are less efficient overall—especially when heating larger areas for longer periods.
If you’re only heating a small space occasionally, an electric heater might be more cost-effective. But for whole-home heating, especially in winter, a heat pump may offer better long-term value.
A heating specialist can help you assess your home’s specific requirements and recommend the best choice for your Melbourne property.
What are the benefits of a heat pump?
Air filtration
Many people don’t realise that heat pumps act as both heaters and air conditioners. In cooling mode, they extract warm air from inside and transfer it outside. In heating mode, they do the reverse—drawing heat from outside and releasing it indoors.
Because they move heat instead of generating it, heat pumps can deliver up to four times the energy they consume.
A major benefit is improved indoor air quality. Standard heating systems often circulate the same air, leading to dust and allergen build-up. A heat pump with an air filtration feature can reduce airborne particles such as pollen, dust, and pet dander.
Heat pumps also help regulate indoor humidity levels—particularly valuable during Melbourne’s humid summer spells.
Environmental sustainability
As concerns about climate change grow, more Australians are embracing renewable energy solutions. Solar panels are a common sight on Melbourne rooftops, but combining solar energy with a heat pump system can maximise sustainability.
While heat pumps do have a higher initial cost than other systems, they are far more efficient. This not only lowers your power bill but also helps reduce your reliance on fossil fuels.
Unlike gas heating, which emits carbon dioxide, heat pumps use electricity—and if paired with solar, that energy can be completely renewable. This makes them one of the best choices for reducing your carbon footprint.
Convenient
Heat pumps are user-friendly and low-maintenance. Once installed, most units can be operated with a simple remote or wall panel. Smart systems can even be controlled via mobile apps, allowing you to adjust your home’s climate on the go.
Safety
According to Australian fire safety guidelines, heating appliances should be kept clear of furniture, curtains, and children. Heat pumps are much safer in this respect—they have no exposed heating elements or flames, reducing the risk of burns or fire.
Energy efficiency
Heat pumps are highly efficient. Rather than creating heat, they transfer it—making them much more energy-smart. In winter, they can be up to four times more efficient than electric resistance heaters. In summer, they can triple the efficiency of a standard air conditioner.
Look for ENERGY STAR® certified heat pumps when shopping, as these models exceed standard efficiency requirements.
For Melbourne’s cooler months, it’s important to choose a unit designed for low outdoor temperatures. Some models are engineered specifically to maintain efficiency in colder conditions.
Although installation is a significant investment, energy savings over time often offset the initial cost.
Dehumidifying mode
Heat pumps aren’t just for heating or cooling—they can also run in dehumidifying mode. This is useful in Melbourne’s humid seasons, especially during spring and autumn, when the weather is warm and damp but doesn’t call for full air conditioning.
By removing excess moisture, your home becomes more comfortable, and you reduce the risk of mould and mildew. If you suffer from allergies or asthma, this feature can also improve air quality by removing irritants like pollen and dust.
Using your heat pump’s dehumidifier function throughout the year helps maintain a healthier and more comfortable indoor climate.
Is a heat pump the right choice for your Melbourne home?
If you’re considering a heat pump for your property, there are a few points to keep in mind. Melbourne can get chilly during winter, especially at night, so you’ll want a model capable of performing well in lower temperatures.
Also, consider the high variability in weather—sometimes intense heat, sometimes cold winds. A properly sized and professionally installed unit will ensure reliable performance year-round.
Heat pumps are efficient and eco-friendly, but they do require regular maintenance. Factor this into your budget and routine when deciding if it’s the right option.
Overall, a heat pump is an excellent heating and cooling solution for Melbourne homes. With long-term savings, energy efficiency, and comfort, it’s a smart investment—just make sure to research and consult experts before you buy.